Why We Love Psychopaths in Fiction
From Hannibal Lecter to my own creation of Bram Alder, fiction is full of cold-blooded, manipulative psychopaths who capture our imagination. These characters commit horrific acts, yet we can’t look away. Why are we so fascinated by them? Why do we find them compelling—even, at times, strangely charismatic?
As a writer, I explore dark psychology in my work, particularly in The Night Nurse, where Bram Alder operates with chilling precision, seducing, manipulating, and exploiting those around him. In crafting him, I delved into the traits that make fictional psychopaths so eerily captivating. Let’s break down the psychology of our obsession.
They Have an Unshakable Confidence
Psychopaths in fiction exude a level of confidence that many people secretly wish they had. They move through the world with no hesitation, no self-doubt. Whether American Psycho’s Patrick Bateman gliding through high society or Hannibal Lecter playing mind games with the FBI, their self-assurance is magnetic.
Unlike real-world psychopaths, who often leave destruction in their wake, fictional ones allow us to live vicariously through their fearlessness without real consequences. We’re drawn to characters who say and do things we never would—but sometimes wish we could.
They’re Masters of Manipulation
Psychopaths in fiction know exactly what to say and how to say it. They charm, deceive, and seduce, making us—and their victims—believe in them. This ability to manipulate makes them unpredictable, which is one of the most effective tools in storytelling.
In my story The Night Nurse (coming soon), Bram Alder’s charm is part of what makes him so dangerous. He can lull people into a false sense of security, making them believe he’s just a dedicated nurse, a caring colleague, even a friend—until they see the monster underneath.
We enjoy watching characters like this because we love the tension of knowing what they are while the other characters remain oblivious. It’s a dramatic irony that keeps us glued to the story.
They Break the Rules—Without Regret
Most of us live within societal constraints. We follow the rules, consider consequences, and feel guilt when we do something wrong. Fictional psychopaths don’t. They act impulsively, take what they want, and do whatever it takes to maintain control.
This makes them exciting because they disrupt the status quo. When Anton Chigurh in No Country for Old Men kills based on a coin toss or Joe Goldberg from You stalks his victims under the guise of love, we’re horrified—but also hooked. Their actions defy moral expectations, and we can’t help but wonder what they’ll do next.
They Challenge Our Sense of Morality
Great psychopaths in fiction blur the line between good and evil. Some even make us root for them. Take Dexter Morgan from Dexter—a serial killer we support because he only targets “bad” people. Even Walter White in Breaking Bad starts as a struggling man we sympathize with, only to transform into someone terrifyingly ruthless.
These characters force us to question our own morality. Why do we justify their actions? At what point do they cross the line? Stories that challenge us in this way are the ones we remember long after we’ve finished them.
We Love the Thrill of the Chase
There’s a reason why crime thrillers and psychological horror are so popular. Fictional psychopaths create tension—we’re constantly wondering when they’ll slip up, when they’ll be exposed, and whether justice will ever be served.
This is why stories like The Silence of the Lambs are so compelling. Hannibal Lecter may be the villain, but we’re equally fascinated by Clarice Starling as she tries to outmaneuver him. The cat-and-mouse dynamic between psychopaths and their pursuers keeps us invested, creating high-stakes storytelling at its best.
Final Thoughts: The Dark Allure of the Psychopath
At the heart of it, our fascination with fictional psychopaths comes from a safe place. We can explore their world without real danger. We can analyze their minds, try to understand them, and even admire their intelligence—all while knowing they’re confined to a book's pages or a TV's screen.
For writers like me, these characters offer endless complexity to explore. In The Night Nurse, Bram Alder embodies many of these traits—his charm, manipulations, and dark appetites. The thrill is in watching how far he can go before the mask finally cracks.
What are your favorite fictional psychopaths? What makes them so compelling to you? Let’s talk in the comments.
Comments